St. Augustine vs. Bermuda Grass: Which is Right for Your Lawn?

‍

Understanding the Contenders: A Quick Overview

St. Augustine Grass

Key Characteristics:
St. Augustine grass is known for its broad, flat blades and dense, carpet-like growth. It boasts a deep green color that gives lawns a rich, vibrant appearance. This grass type establishes quickly and provides excellent ground coverage, making it a favorite for residential lawns and shaded areas.

Ideal For:
St. Augustine thrives in warm, humid climates and is especially well-suited for coastal regions. It performs well in partial shade, making it a great option for yards with trees or buildings that block sunlight for parts of the day.

Bermuda Grass

Key Characteristics:
Bermuda grass features a fine texture, rapid growth rate, and high durability. Its aggressive spreading habit allows it to quickly fill in bare spots, and it forms a tight, resilient turf that can withstand heavy use.

Ideal For:
Bermuda grass excels in full sun and hot climates, making it ideal for open lawns, sports fields, and high-traffic areas. Its toughness and drought resistance make it a go-to choice for homeowners seeking a low-maintenance yet hard-wearing lawn.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Key Factors

Climate and Growing Zones

• St. Augustine: Thrives in USDA Zones 8–10, but struggles in areas with extended cold snaps.
• Bermuda: Performs well in Zones 7–10 and is more cold-tolerant than St. Augustine.
• Expert Tip: Always check your local USDA hardiness zone before selecting turfgrass.

Sunlight and Shade Tolerance

• St. Augustine: Tolerates moderate shade and grows well with at least 4–6 hours of sun daily.
• Bermuda: Requires full sun (6–8+ hours); struggles significantly in shaded areas.
• Pro Tip: Use a sunlight map or diagram to compare shade coverage on your property.

Watering Needs & Drought Tolerance

• St. Augustine: Requires consistent moisture and struggles during drought without irrigation.
• Bermuda: Highly drought-tolerant thanks to a deep root system and can recover well from dry periods.

Maintenance Requirements

Mowing:

• St. Augustine: Best kept at 3–4 inches; slower growth means less frequent mowing.
• Bermuda: Needs regular mowing at 1–2 inches due to fast, aggressive growth.

Fertilization:

• St. Augustine: Requires 4–5 lbs of nitrogen per 1,000 sq. ft. annually.
• Bermuda: Requires 2–4 lbs of nitrogen per 1,000 sq. ft. annually.

Weed Control:

• Both: Dense growth helps prevent weed establishment.
• Note: Use pre-emergent herbicides in early spring and spot-treat as needed.

Thatch Buildup:

• St. Augustine: Prone to thatch buildup—annual dethatching may be necessary.
• Bermuda: Less prone but can still develop thatch in over-fertilized or over-watered lawns.

Pest and Disease Susceptibility

• St. Augustine: Vulnerable to chinch bugs, gray leaf spot, and brown patch.
• Bermuda: Generally more resilient but can face armyworms, grubs, and spring dead spot.

Traffic Tolerance & Recovery

• St. Augustine: Moderate traffic tolerance and slow to recover from heavy wear.
• Bermuda: Excellent traffic tolerance with rapid self-repair, making it ideal for active lawns.

Appearance and Texture

• St. Augustine: Coarse texture, wide blades, and a thick, plush feel underfoot.
• Bermuda: Fine texture, dense coverage, and a uniform, manicured appearance.

Salt Tolerance

• St. Augustine: Excellent salt tolerance, great for coastal properties.
• Bermuda: Varies by variety—some hybrids offer good salt tolerance.

Cost

Initial Installation:

• St. Augustine: Usually sold as sod or plugs—higher initial cost.
• Bermuda: Available as sod or seed—generally more budget-friendly if seeding.

Ongoing Maintenance:

• St. Augustine: May cost more due to higher water and fertilizer needs.

Bermuda: Lower ongoing costs thanks to drought tolerance and hardiness.

Final Thoughts: Which Grass Should You Choose?

Choosing between St. Augustine and Bermuda grass ultimately comes down to your local conditions, lifestyle, and lawn goals. If you have shade and want a softer, carpet-like feel, St. Augustine may be the better fit. If you want a tough, sun-loving lawn that bounces back from foot traffic, Bermuda could be the clear winner.

Before committing, take stock of your property’s sunlight exposure, climate zone, irrigation setup, and how much maintenance you’re willing to take on. A little planning now can lead to years of satisfaction with your lawn.

Still unsure? Reach out to a local turf expert or lawn care provider for tailored advice—and be sure to check out our other lawn care guides to help you grow the yard you’ve always wanted.

‍